The Beatles

[Gereon Rath]

The Beatles rangert 1 til 10

10  Perfekt

9 Fantastisk

8  Ekstremt bra

7  Veldig bra

6  Bra

5  Middelmådig

4  Ikke veldig bra

3  Dårlig

2  Veldig dårlig

1  Elendig

Please Please Me

Spoiler

I Saw Her Standing There -7.5
Misery - 7.9
Anna (Go To Him) - 7.2
Chains - 7.5
Boys - 7
Ask Me Why -7.1
Please Please Me - 7.3
Love Me Do - 7.8
P.S. I Love You - 6.2
Baby It's You - 6.6
Do You Want To Know A Secret -6,4
A Taste Of Honey-7.7
There's A Place -7.1
Twist And Shout -7.3

6.6
-------------------------------------------------------------
With The Beatles

Spoiler

It Won't Be Long -7,9
All I've Got To Do -7.7
All My Loving -7.8
Don't Bother Me - 7.9
Little Child - 7.2
Till There Was You - 7.5
Please Mr Postman - 7.7
Roll Over Beethoven - 7.6
Hold Me Tight - 7.3
You Really Got A Hold On Me - 7.2
I Wanna Be Your Man - 7.3
Devil In Her Heart - 7.1
Not A Second Time - 6.8
Money (That's What I Want) - 6.9

7,4
-----------------------------------------------------------------
A Hard Day`s Night

Spoiler

A Hard Day's Night -8.1
I Should Have Known Better - 7,3
If I Fell - 7.5
I'm Happy Just To Dance With You - 7
And I Love Her - 7.1
Tell Me Why - 7,2
Can't Buy Me Love - 8.5
Any Time At All - 7.5
I'll Cry Instead - 7.3
Things We Said Today -7.3
When I Get Home - 7,4
You Can't Do That - 7.3
I'll Be Back - 7.2

7,4
------------------------------------------------------------------
Beatles for Sale

Spoiler

No Reply 8.5
I'm A Loser 8.1
Baby's In Black 8,3
Rock And Roll Music 8.2
I'll Follow The Sun 7.7
Mr Moonlight 7.5
Kansas City / Hey-Hey-Hey-Hey 7,3
Eight Days A Week 8.7
Words Of Love 7.3
Honey Don't 7.2
Every Little Thing 7,3
I Don't Want To Spoil The Party 6.4
What You're Doing 6.6
Everybody's Trying To Be My Baby 7

7.5
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Help

Spoiler

Help!-9.5
The Night Before-8.6
You've Got To Hide Your Love Away-9.2
I Need You-8.8
Another Girl-8.3
You're Going To Lose That Girl-8.3
Ticket To Ride-9
Act Naturally-8.4
It's Only Love-8
You Like Me Too Much-8.3
Tell Me What You See-8.2
I've Just Seen A Face-8.1
Yesterday-10
Dizzy Miss Lizzy- 8.4

8,5
----------------------------------------------------------------
Rubber Soul

Spoiler

Drive My Car - 9.3
Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown) -10
You Won't See Me - 9.1
Nowhere Man -10
Think For Yourself - 9.5
The Word - 8.8
Michelle - 8.5
What Goes On -8.8
Girl - 8.2
I'm Looking Through You - 10
In My Life -10
Wait - 8.9
If I Needed Someone -8.4
Run For Your Life - 8.3

9.1
------------------------------------------------------
Revolver

Spoiler

Taxman - 9.3
Eleanor Rigby - 10
I´m Only Sleeping - 9.1
Love You To - 8.4
Here There And Everywhere - 9.5
Yellow Submarine - 8.5
She Said She Said - 8.8
Good Day Sunshine - 8.6
And Your Bird Can Sing - 8,6
For No One - 9
Doctor Robert - 9.1
I Want To Tell You - 9.2
Got To Get You Into My Life - 8.7
Tomorrow Never Knows - 9

8.9
---------------------------------------------------------------
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band

Spoiler

Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - 9
With A Little Help From My Friends - 9.1
Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds -10
Getting Better - 10
Fixing A Hole - 9.4
She's Leaving Home - 8.9
Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite! - 9.6
Within You Without You - 9.2
When I'm Sixty Four - 9
Lovely Rita - 9
Good Morning Good Morning - 9
Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise) - 9
A Day In The Life - 10

9.3
------------------------------------------------------------------
Magical Mystery Tour

Spoiler

Magical Mystery Tour 7,5
The Fool On The Hill 7,7
Flying 7.3
Blue Jay Way 7.3
Your Mother Should Know 5
I Am The Walrus 8.9
Hello Goodbye 9.4
Strawberry Fields Forever 10
Penny Lane 10
Baby You're A Rich Man 8.3
All You Need Is Love 8

8,1
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The White Album

Spoiler

Back In The U.S.S.R. - 9.8
Dear Prudence - 9.7
Glass Onion - 9.5
Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da - 8.3
Wild Honey Pie - 8.9
The Continuing Story Of Bungalow Bill - 8.8
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 10
Happiness Is A Warm Gun - 9.2
Martha My Dear - 8.9
I'm So Tired - 9
Blackbird - 10
Piggies - 9.3
Rocky Racoon - 9.4
Don't Pass Me By - 8.4
Why Don't We Do It In The Road? - 8.3
I Will - 8.3
Julia - 9.1
Birthday - 8.3
Yer Blues - 8.8
Mother Nature's Son - 8.3
Everybody's Got Something To Hide Except Me And My Monkey -8.1
Sexy Sadie - 8.3
Helter Skelter - 9.1
Long, Long, Long - 8.7
Revolution - 10
Honey Pie - 8.2
Savoy Truffle - 9.3
Cry Baby Cry - 9.1
Revolution 9 - 1
Good Night - 8.8

8.6
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yellow Submarine

Spoiler

Yellow Submarine - 8.5
Only A Northern Song - 8.6
All Together Now - 7.4
Hey Bulldog - 8.2
It's All Too Much - 7.5
All You Need Is Love - 8
Pepperland - 5
Sea Of Time - 5
Sea Of Holes - 5
Sea Of Monsters - 5
March Of The Meanies - 5
Pepperland Laid Waste - 5
Yellow Submarine In Pepperland - 5

6.4
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Abby Road

Spoiler

Come Together - 10
Something - 10
Maxwell's Silver Hammer - 9.3
Oh! Darling - 9.2
Octopus's Garden - 9.1
I Want You (She's So Heavy) - 9.3
Here Comes The Sun - 10
Because - 9
You Never Give Me Your Money - 9.1
Sun King - 9.2
Mean Mr Mustard - 9.3
Polythene Pam - 9,4
She Came In Through The Bathroom Window - 9.1
Golden Slumbers - 9,3
Carry That Weight - 9.5
The End - 9.1
Her Majesty - 9

 9.3
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Let It Be

Spoiler

Two Of Us -8
Dig A Pony - 7,9
Across The Universe - 9.3
I Me Mine -7,5
Dig It - 7,9
Let It Be - 10
Maggie Mae - 8.2
I’ve Got A Feeling - 8.3
One After 909 - 8.1
The Long And Winding Road - 10
For You Blue - 7,8
Get Back - 10

8,5
---------------------------------------------------------------
Album Ranking

Spoiler

Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band= 9.3
Abby Road= 9.3
Rubber Soul=9.1
Revolver= 8.9
The White Album= 8.6
Help= 8,5
Let It Be = 8,5
Magical Mystery Tour= 8,1
Beatles for Sale=7.5
With The Beatles= 7,4
A Hard Day`s Night= 7,4
Please Please Me = 6.6
Yellow Submarine = 6.4

8,1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sanger som ikke var på noe album

Spoiler

From Me To You - 6.6
Thank You Girl -6.4
She Loves You -7.2
I’ll Get You- 6,8
I Want To Hold Your Hand -6
This Boy -6,4
Slow Down -7,4
Matchbox - 7.1
Long Tall Sally - 7.3
I Call Your Name - 7,1
I Feel Fine - 9.5
She’s A Woman - 7
Yes It Is - 6.8
Bad Boy - 6.9
I’m Down - 7.3
We Can Work It Out - 9.5
Day Tripper- 9.3
Paperback Writer - 9.6
Rain - 9.3
Lady Madonna - 8.4
The Inner Light - 8.3
Hey Jude - 9.2
Don’t Let Me Down - 9.6
The Ballad Of John And Yoko - 7.9
Old Brown Shoe - 7.3
You Know My Name (Look Up the Number) - 4.3

[AnonymBruker]

Som en som setter stor pris på The Beatles, er jeg enig i mye her, men at for eksempel Sun King får like god karakter som Hey Jude, og bedre karakter enn Because, er helt uforståelig for meg; hvis Getting Better får 10, er det ingenting som tilsier at Hey Jude og Because er soleklare 10-ere:

Mens harmoniene i Because er av en annen verden:

Dessuten synes jeg også noen av de tidlige coverlåtene får for dårlig karakter i forhold til måten Beatles bearbeider disse på; Please Mr Postman og Rock And Roll Music er eksempler på sanger som høres langt bedre ut i Beatles' hender - her er originalen:

Og her er The Beatles:

Det er tross alt en viss forskjell, og 7.7 gjenspeiler ikke dette.

Samme med Rock And Roll Music; originalen er grei nok:

Mens Beatles' versjon svinger virkelig, og det de har gjort med sangen, fortjener etter min mening mer enn 8.2:

- B.

Anonymkode: e71ec...e2c

[AnonymBruker]

10 minutter siden, AnonymBruker said:

Som en som setter stor pris på The Beatles, er jeg enig i mye her, men at for eksempel Sun King får like god karakter som Hey Jude, og bedre karakter enn Because, er helt uforståelig for meg; hvis Getting Better får 10, er det ingenting som tilsier at Hey Jude og Because er soleklare 10-ere:

Anonymkode: e71ec...e2c

Unnskyld skrivefeil; mente selvfølgelig at det ingenting som tilsier at Hey Jude og Because ikke er soleklare 10-ere.

- B.

Anonymkode: e71ec...e2c

[AnonymBruker]

Dessuten synes jeg også at karakteren 1 til Revolution 9 er hardt bedømt; nå er jo ikke dette akkurat noen danselåt, og er noe John Lennon typisk nok kunne finne på etter å ha blitt kjent med Yoko Ono, men i lys av sangens kreative vinkling som passer godt inn i tidsånden der det var om å gjøre å sprenge grenser og være avant-garde, fortjener Revolution 9 etter min mening litt bedre; man kan sette den på fullt volum når naboen er fyllsyk:

- B.

Anonymkode: e71ec...e2c

[Gereon Rath]

AnonymBruker skrev (4 timer siden):

Unnskyld skrivefeil; mente selvfølgelig at det ingenting som tilsier at Hey Jude og Because ikke er soleklare 10-ere.

- B.

Anonymkode: e71ec...e2c

Folk har forskjellige meninger om sanger, for deg er de 10 for meg er de ikke det.